Skip to content
← Immigration resources

ARTICLE · IMMIGRATION

Does My Caddie Need a P-1S Visa?

Originally published on usavisaway.comOriginal source

By Christopher P. Chaney, Esq.

For years, many international golfers and their caddies have relied on B-1/B-2 visitor visas (or ESTA, the Visa Waiver Program equivalent) to enter the United States for tournaments. It felt workable, predictable, and relatively low risk. If prize money was the only compensation and the player maintained a base abroad, entry was usually uneventful.

That reality is shifting. Quietly, but consistently.

We are now seeing more cases where caddies, especially those traveling repeatedly on U.S.-centered schedules, are questioned at the port of entry. Sometimes they are admitted with a warning. Sometimes they are admitted after extended questioning. Increasingly, the real issue shows up on the next trip. A prior warning tends to follow the traveler, and the next inspection becomes more difficult.

The question is no longer just whether caddying fits within the technical language of the B-1 rules. The question is whether, in practice, it looks like a job in the United States. That shift is making the P-1S visa increasingly necessary.

Who Can Get a P-1S and the Structural Gap in the Law

The P-1S visa is designed for essential support personnel of a P-1A visa athlete. This includes caddies, trainers, and coaches whose services are integral and cannot be readily replaced by a U.S. worker.

The key limitation is structural. The P-1S only exists if the golfer is in P-1A status. If the golfer is a lawful permanent resident or a U.S. citizen, there is no P-1 framework to attach to. The caddie cannot independently obtain a P-1S. This creates a real gap in the legal system. Some of the most established players on tour, who have already transitioned to green card or U.S. citizenship, are the ones whose caddies have the fewest options.

There is a parallel concept in the O category, which is for individuals of extraordinary ability in fields such as athletics, arts, and business. zIf the athlete is in O-1 visa status, support personnel may qualify for an O-2 visa. But this framework is similarly limited. The O-2 is tied to the O-1 principal and requires an active petitioning structure. It does not solve the problem where the athlete is already a lawful permanent resident or U.S. citizen, and no qualifying underlying status exists.

In those situations, the remaining paths are limited. ESTA or B-1 may still be used, but as we discuss below - only if the facts support it. Other visa categories generally do not fit well. This leads to inconsistent outcomes where two caddies doing the same job face very different risks depending entirely on the golfer’s immigration status.

B-1 for Athletes and Support Personnel: The FAM Framework

The starting point is the Foreign Affairs Manual guidance governing the use of B-1 visitor visas for athletic participation and related support activities. The relevant provision at 9 FAM 402.2-5(C)(4) was revised in September 2025 and now provides:


Professional athletes who receive no salary or payment from a U.S. source other than prize money for their participation in a tournament or sporting event may be issued a visa if:

(1) The foreign athlete's principal place of business or activity is in a foreign country;

(2) The athlete's salary principally accrues in a foreign country; and

(3) If the foreign athlete plays a team-based sport, the foreign-based sports team is a member of an international sports league, or the sporting activities involved have an international dimension.


Previously, the rule was applied with broad flexibility. Athletes competing for prize money could often rely on B-1 classification so long as they were not receiving U.S.-source salary, even without clearly demonstrating a foreign base of operations. The updated approach places greater weight on where the athlete’s professional life is actually centered. Concepts like principal place of activity and where income accrues are now at the forefront of the analysis.

In practice, this makes it significantly more difficult for athletes whose training, competition, or daily routines are primarily based in the United States. This includes post-collegiate athletes who remain in U.S. training environments, independent athletes who are not really making money outside the U.S., and others whose schedules, income, or professional ties are increasingly centered in the United States.

The September 2025 update to 9 FAM 402.2-5(C)(4) also directly addresses support personnel:


Many individual and team-based sports rely on necessary personnel who support the professional athletes. Such personnel encompass a wide variety of roles, and each play a necessary part in the individual athlete's or team's ability to successfully perform. Necessary personnel may be issued a B-1 visa if:

(1) They perform, for compensation, the same or similar services abroad for the individual athlete or foreign sports team;

(2) The athlete or foreign sports team has their principal place of business or activity in a foreign country; and

(3) Their salary principally accrues in a foreign country.


On paper, this language appears to accommodate caddies. A caddie can often satisfy each element. They work with the same golfer globally, are paid abroad, and can point to a foreign-based professional relationship.

In practice, that is no longer enough. When a caddie is traveling week-to-week on a U.S.-centered schedule and working continuously alongside the golfer, the arrangement begins to look less like temporary foreign support and more like ongoing work tied to U.S. competition.

At the border, this has translated into a more searching inquiry. Officers are not just asking how the arrangement is structured, but whether the overall pattern of activity reflects a foreign-based professional life.

The Core Tension: Where the Theory Meets Reality

This is where the legal framework and real-world practice begin to diverge.

Under the Foreign Affairs Manual, a caddie can potentially fit within the structure if the same services are performed abroad, the golfer’s principal place of activity remains outside the United States, and the salary accrues abroad. On paper, that analysis can still be made.

But when the golfer is in P-1A status, the context changes.

A P-1A golfer has a U.S. petitioner, is competing in a U.S.-organized structure such as the LPGA Tour, and often has a season that is heavily anchored in the United States. That signals to CBP that this is not just occasional participation. It begins to look like a U.S.-based professional operation.

With the September 2025 update, CBP no longer asks simply whether the payment structure fits the B-1 rule. Now, officers focus on where the work is performed and how regularly the individual is in the United States. Which leads to the question: if this is a U.S.-based competition structure, why don't you have a P visa?

When the “Paid Abroad” Theory Still Works

There are still scenarios where caddies can justify working under an ESTA or B-1, even where the golfer holds P-1A status.

This tends to be the case where the athlete maintains a genuinely international profile. The golfer lives and trains abroad, competes globally, and does not have a season that is concentrated in the United States. The caddie works with the golfer worldwide, is paid directly by the golfer abroad, and is not tied to a U.S. petitioner or sponsor.

In that setting, the argument still holds that the principal place of activity remains abroad and that the income structure is foreign. The caddie can be framed as foreign-based support personnel temporarily entering the United States.

Legally, this position is moderate in strength. At inspection, it can still be viable, but it is highly dependent on the facts and how the travel pattern looks over time.

Where the Analysis Starts Breaking Down

The risk increases once the facts begin to shift toward a U.S.-centered season.

When most tournaments are in the United States, stays become longer, and entries more frequent, CBP is less likely to view the activity as temporary. At that point, the issue is no longer just how the arrangement is structured, but whether the overall pattern looks like ongoing work tied to a U.S.-based competition schedule.

A related concern is how closely the caddie is integrated into the golfer’s day-to-day operations. A caddie who travels the full schedule and works continuously with the same player begins to look less like independent support and more like part of a regular working team.

The fact that compensation is paid abroad still matters, but it no longer carries the analysis on its own.

The Shift at the Border

In practice, U.S. Customs and Border Protection is applying a more practical, experience-based analysis.

Officers are looking at the location of the activity, the continuity of presence, and the degree of integration into U.S. competition. The question becomes whether this looks like temporary foreign activity or ongoing work tied to the United States.

This explains why warnings at the port of entry have become more frequent. A warning is not a minor event. It often signals that the officer has already identified the issue. On the next entry, the same facts are viewed with less tolerance.

The pattern we are seeing is consistent. Initial questioning is followed by a warning: you can't do this type of work with a B-1 visa. But if this happens mid-season, with the next U.S. tournament already on the schedule, what are you supposed to do? It puts both the caddie and golfer in a difficult position, especially given the risks around unauthorized work. And once the tour moves to the next international location, reentry on B-1 or ESTA becomes much more uncertain.

When to Consider Filing a P-1S

The decision to file a P-1S is ultimately about aligning the legal structure with how the season actually looks.

A simple way to frame this: does this look like a temporary foreign support role, or does it look like a regular job supporting a U.S.-based competition schedule?

If the caddie is traveling occasionally and the golfer maintains a clearly international base, visitor status may still be workable. But once the season becomes U.S.-centered and the caddie is present on a consistent basis, the risk increases significantly.

A border encounter is often the clearest trigger. If a caddie has been questioned, warned, or specifically told that ESTA or B-1 is not appropriate and that a P classification should be used, that should be taken seriously. At that point, the issue has already been identified, and the likelihood of problems at the next entry increases.

How the P-1S Works in Practice

A P-1S petition is filed by a U.S. petitioner, which may be the P-1A athlete, an agent, or a management entity. The filing must establish that the caddie provides essential support and has a longstanding working relationship that cannot be easily replaced.

Timing can be managed strategically. With premium processing, adjudication can be expedited, making mid-season filings realistic if coordinated properly. However, there is an important practical difference between ESTA and B-1. A B-1 visa allows for a change of status inside the United States. In the right circumstances, this can make it possible to transition to P-1S without departing, which can be valuable when timing is tight. ESTA does not allow for change of status. A caddie entering under ESTA must complete the process through consular processing abroad. That means leaving the United States, securing the visa, and reentering.

The key is planning around travel. Depending on the situation, the caddie may change status inside the United States or complete consular processing abroad. Both paths can work, but the timing must be handled carefully to avoid disrupting tournament participation.

How Long Can a P-1S Last

An initial P-1S approval is typically granted for up to one year, tied to the underlying P-1A petition.

However, extensions can go beyond one year if the underlying P-1A is extended for a longer period, up to five years. In practice, this allows the caddie to remain in valid status over multiple seasons, tracking the golfer’s ongoing competition schedule.

This creates stability. Instead of navigating repeated entries under uncertain visitor classifications, the caddie operates within a framework that matches the reality of the professional relationship.

Final Thoughts: Aligning Structure with Reality

The core issue in 2026 is alignment. The legal framework needs to match how the season actually operates.

If the season is clearly centered in the United States and the caddie is traveling on B-1 or ESTA, it is best to address the issue proactively. Waiting until a problem arises at the border can create unnecessary risk. If a caddie is denied reentry after an international swing, the disruption to the golfer's rhythm can be serious.

For caddies working with U.S. citizens or permanent residents, the recent revision to the Foreign Affairs Manual significantly limits the available options. In some cases, it may be worth exploring an O-1 visa, which is reserved for individuals who can demonstrate extraordinary ability in their field.

For caddies working with P-1A golfers, applying for a P-1S brings the legal structure in line with the reality of the role. That alignment will keep you out of the bunker and the season on track.

>> Explore P Visas Legal Services

>> Meet Our Attorney

>> Learn About Our Legal Consultations


If you have any questions about the services or legal fees at Chaney Immigration Law Firm, feel free to call and speak with a member of our team - (888) 880-9266.

KEEP READING

More immigration articles